Michael Carrick is strengthening a strong claim for the Manchester United job, and Ryan Giggs believes Ruben Amorim deserves some credit. Giggs feels Amorim’s signings gave Carrick a useful platform, even though Amorim’s spell brought poor results and criticism from fans and media across the 14 months in charge at Old Trafford.
Carrick has now overseen 14 Premier League matches for Manchester United across two caretaker spells and has won nine of them. That 64% win rate places Carrick second in the club’s Premier League history, just behind Alex Ferguson’s 65%, and comes as United chase a top-five finish and Champions League qualification.
United’s numbers under different managers underline the contrast. Amorim left with a 32% Premier League win rate, winning 15 of 47 games, which is the lowest figure recorded by any Manchester United manager. Carrick’s current 64% record stands out, especially given the pressure around the club during the 2025-26 campaign.
{TABLE_1}
Amorim’s departure was confirmed on January 5, ending a difficult reign that began with optimism after Sporting CP. Manchester United endured their worst Premier League season in 2024-25 under Amorim, finishing 15th with 42 points, and also lost to Tottenham in the Europa League final, adding further scrutiny on the project.
The first half of the 2025-26 season brought some recovery, with Manchester United rising to sixth in the table. However, Amorim publicly questioned the club hierarchy and demanded a bigger role in recruitment, which hastened his exit. Despite the poor league record, several recruits from Amorim’s time have become important figures for Carrick.
Players such as Benjamin Sesko, Bryan Mbeumo, Matheus Cunha and Senne Lammens were all brought in under Ruben Amorim. Those signings have delivered solid performances under Michael Carrick, helping stabilise results and offering more balance to the squad, which Giggs feels reflects one positive aspect of Amorim’s management at Manchester United.
Giggs discussed the topic on Rio Ferdinand Presents and offered a more balanced view of Amorim’s work, saying: “A sign of a good manager is the team that he leaves behind. Ruben Amorim took a lot of stick for the way that he played. I didn’t enjoy watching it but actually, I think some of his signings have been good and I think we’re now seeing that now. Even though his legacy probably isn’t great with results and performances, he’s probably left the club, and the players that he got out, in a pretty good place.”
Michael Carrick Ruben Amorim Manchester United future prospects
Giggs believes Carrick has already shown qualities needed for long-term success at Manchester United. The former winger sees clear progress in results, even if Carrick has had limited time to reshape the team’s style. Giggs also underlined how modern managers must adapt quickly, with patience and long projects far less common than before.
Speaking about Carrick’s impact, Giggs added: “There’s positivity from me because the hardest thing to do as a manager is win games and he’s winning games. It’s hard at this time of the season to really stamp your own philosophy, your own principles of play. I think every manager that goes into a role now is like an interim, because you don’t get time. I think 20 to 30 years ago you were looking at the long-term. You’re buying players, young players, who are maybe not right yet but in two or three years’ time they’ll be great for the club. You can’t do that anymore.You’ve got to work short-term and long-term, and I think Michael will do that.”
The club highlighted Carrick’s current role with a social media post, reflecting the growing backing around the interim manager among supporters. The message came as United continued their climb up the table and as discussion increases over whether Carrick should move from interim status to a permanent appointment at Old Trafford.
Manchester United’s next fixture is at home to Brentford on April 27, when Carrick’s side will aim to secure their position in the Premier League’s top five. With Champions League qualification now within reach and several Ruben Amorim signings contributing, results across the coming weeks may shape both Carrick’s future and the club’s wider direction.
Get breaking news alerts.
Allow Notifications
You have already subscribed
Story first published: Tuesday, April 21, 2026, 16:32 [IST]
